Management Strategies

11:41 AM
Art Gillis
Art Gillis
Commentary
50%
50%

What Didn't the Banking Crunch Or Great Recession Change in Banking?

Answer: The net reduction rate in financial institution population.

If the past three years have been the worst since the Great Depression, why is it we didn't lose at least 30% of the banks? We didn't and the numbers don't lie.

There's a huge difference, of course, if the shrinkage is due to M&A activity where sellers used to get three times book value, rather than today's quitters who are lucky to get 10% of the value of their OREO portfolio. But it still seems to me there's some kind of regulatory control going on at 20th St. and Constitution Ave. in DC that wants to see a decline in the number of banks. So while all the attention is on the FDIC and others holding the padlocks, the Fed appears to be happy with the consistent decline so as to look more like the old countries where we all came from.

The decline has been going on forever it seems. I started tracking in 1994. Every pundit had an opinion. Some were radical, like "There will be two thousand banks in the U.S." The Jersey banker who made that prediction is now working at Jersey Shore, I think.

Decline in the Number of U.S. Financial Institutions
YearNumberRate of Decline
2010152193.65%
2009157963.53%
2008163743.0%
2007168812.43%
2006173022.9%
2005178232.35%
2004182512.67%
2003187525.2%
2002192503.3%
2001199012.66%
2000204453.03%
1999210843.43%
1998218293.0%
1997225052.91%
1996231804.0%
1995241434.58%
199425302

Conclusion: If the statisticians use three measures to determine the nature of a situation, then it would appear that 2010 at 3.65% was not that far out of their range. Pass the champagne.

Mean: 3.3%

Median: 3%

Mode: 3%

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Register for Bank Systems & Technology Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
Bank Systems & Technology - August 2014
Modern core systems are emerging as the foundations of effective channel integration and customer engagement initiatives.
Slideshows
Video
Bank Systems & Technology Radio
Archived Audio Interviews
New IT Models for New Financial Services Challenges